“20+ years’ experience.” It’s right there at the top of the CV, usually the first line under the name, and it’s there because for most of your career it was the thing that did the work. You put it in the room before you walked in.
Now picture the other side of the table. Somebody in procurement, or a finance director, or a founder who’s had a bad quarter, has a spreadsheet open. There’s a column for price. There’s a column for turnaround. Maybe one for quality, if they’re being thorough, some sort of score. I’ve sat with a lot of business owners going through spreadsheets like that over the last year or so, and I have never once seen a column for years.
That’s going to annoy some people, and I understand why. Twenty years is a lot of life. It’s late nights and the client you kept when everyone said you’d lose them and all the stuff you learned by getting it wrong in front of people. That’s real, and I’m not saying it didn’t count. It counted. The question is what it was being paid for.
Because when you think about it, the years were always a proxy. Nobody was really buying the years. They were buying what the years usually meant, which was that you’d do it faster, you’d do it with fewer mistakes, you’d spot the thing in the brief that a junior would miss, and so on. The experience was a sort of shorthand for all of that. And a big chunk of all of that, the doing it faster, the not making mistakes in the routine bit, the turning a messy brief into a tidy first draft, is exactly the chunk these tools have got good at. In chapter 2 of the book I put judgement, context and relationships at maybe a fifth of the day for someone in a coordinating role. Maybe a fifth. The other four-fifths is the stuff your twenty years made you quick at, and quick has just been priced at roughly nothing.
So the years still buy you the fifth. That fifth is real and it’s valuable and I wouldn’t swap it. It’s just a lot less day than the CV is claiming.
Now, someone will say, hang on, the data says experienced people are fine. And they’re sort of right, at the moment. The Stanford Digital Economy Lab, working from ADP payroll data, has been tracking employment in AI-exposed occupations, and in their latest update the experienced workers show no comparable gap. The effect so far is concentrated at the start of careers. I’d read that as a lag rather than a pass. If you’re already in post, nobody is re-buying you every Monday morning. You get re-bought when you move, or when the contract comes up, or when the restructure lands and somebody has to decide which roles carry on. Or when you decide to go, which people tend to forget is the same thing.
The awkward bit is that most people with twenty years haven’t been on the market in a while, so they haven’t seen the spreadsheet yet. They’ve seen the CV.
There’s a line in chapter 15 I come back to a lot: “The version of success you were sold at twenty-two is not the version that exists now.” That’s a structural thing, and the book’s pretty clear you’re not being asked to admit your career was a mistake. It wasn’t. You did the deal that was on the table. The deal changed after you’d signed it, which happens, it’s just rarely this fast.
I don’t think the answer is to hide the twenty years, either, or to pretend you’re thirty-two and digitally native or whatever. I think it’s knowing which bits of it are still being paid for, specifically, by name, so that when someone asks what they’re getting for your rate you can point at the fifth and say that, that’s it, that’s what you’re buying.
The Next Rung has the eighty/twenty split in chapter 2 and what to do with it in chapter 15. Paperback, Practical Inspiration Publishing, 19 January, and the pre-order is at thenextrung.co.
Go through last week and mark which tasks needed the twenty years and which ones only needed the login.

The Next Rung is a book on how AI is quietly dismantling the middle of knowledge work, and what you can do about it before the market decides for you: pre-order it before it publishes in January.

