You’ve heard it at leaving drinks. You might have said it at leaving drinks, a couple of glasses in, someone asks what’s next and it comes out easy: “I’ll go consulting.” Do a bit of freelance, pick up some of the old clients, be my own boss for a bit and see where it goes.
And if you’re still in a job, it’s probably your plan too, somewhere. Not a plan exactly. More like a door you’ve noticed at the back of the room. If this place goes the way everyone’s whispering about, I’ll go through that door, and on the other side there’s day rates and choosing your own hours and not having to sit through the Monday meeting.
I want to talk about that door, because I think a lot of people are relying on it without having looked through it recently.
Here’s what happened on the other side of it. A group of researchers, Xiang Hui, Oren Reshef and Luofeng Zhou, looked at what went on at Upwork after ChatGPT came out, and what Midjourney and the image tools did to the design side. Writing jobs on the platform dropped, and the money dropped with them, and it happened within months. And the bit that stuck with me, when they published it in Organization Science, was that the freelancers who’d been earning the most beforehand took the biggest hit. The good ones. The people who’d done it properly. Which makes sense when you think about it for a second, because freelance work is already a task with a price tag on it. Somebody has already chopped it out of a job, written a brief, put a number next to it. That’s the easiest kind of work there is to swap for a subscription. So the cheap competitor showed up there first, before it showed up in your office.
Which means that the door at the back of the room opens onto the first place the water got to.
That’s the fear, really, and I don’t think people say it out loud much. It goes something like: I might lose my job, and the thing I was going to do instead might already be going as well. Two floors gone at once.
In chapter 11 of The Next Rung there’s a former financial analyst called Ryan, a composite, who ends up doing three platform jobs at once. Content moderation, a bit of freelance data work, delivery driving. After the platform cuts and his costs he’s on about eighteen grand. Picture eighteen grand with Slough rent coming out of it. He’s the one out of six in that chapter who didn’t come through, and the difference between him and the others wasn’t effort. He worked as hard as any of them. Amara, another composite in the same chapter, runs three part-time things and it works for her, mostly because her rent was capped by a housing co-op. Same sort of portfolio. One had a floor under it and one didn’t.
I don’t think the answer is never go freelance. Plenty of people will do it and do it well, and a lot of the businesses I work with are going to need outside help more than ever over the next few years, just a different kind of help. In chapter 15 I call it navigator rather than optimiser. “I’ll do your marketing” is the bit a subscription does now. “I’ll help you work out what’s changing and where you need to stand” is a different conversation, and it’s a smaller number of conversations, and you have to be able to have it with someone who’s already tried asking the tool first. Which most of them have.
I’m talking about this at GEO Elite today, as it happens. The talk’s called The £30 Competitor, which is where the title came from, and it’s mostly about who that competitor turned up for first.
The Next Rung is out on 19 January, paperback, Practical Inspiration Publishing. Ryan and Amara are in chapter 11. thenextrung.co if you want it.
Name three people who’d pay your day rate next month. Then ask yourself whether each of them already has a ChatGPT login.

The Next Rung is a book on how AI is quietly dismantling the middle of knowledge work, and what you can do about it before the market decides for you: pre-order it before it publishes in January.

