On Thursday night I did a talk to parents in Chigwell, and when it got to the questions the first hand up asked “So what you’re saying is everyone should learn to be a Plumber or Carpenter?”. And then a couple of people later, somebody else asked “If grades are not going to ‘last’, why should we bother pushing our children to do their homework and grades?”.
I should say I don’t have children. So I was probably the one person in that room without skin in this particular game, which made it easier for me to hear what was actually being asked. Because both of those questions, and most of the ones in between, were really the same question. If we get the grades right, they’ll be alright, won’t they?
And I understand why. For about the last fifty years that’s been basically true. Get the grades, get into the decent university, and then the credential sort of carries you. It was a pretty good deal and a lot of the parents in that room did exactly that, and it worked for them, and they’re paying for it to work again.
Here’s the problem with it, or one of them anyway. Think about what an exam actually tests. Recall, structured writing to a mark scheme, working through a known kind of problem in a set time, producing a tidy answer that matches what the examiner expects. Now think about what these tools are good at. It’s pretty much the same list. In chapter 13 of the book I put it like this: “When the work the exam selects for is the work the technology replaces first, the proxy breaks.” The exam was always a proxy. Nobody hired anyone for being good at exams, they hired them because being good at exams used to mean you’d probably be good at the work. And the work it was predicting is the work going first.
There’s a line in chapter 3 that people find uncomfortable, and parents especially: “The spinning jenny displaced the illiterate weaver. The assembly line displaced the unskilled labourer. AI is displacing the educated professional.” The credential was supposed to be the thing that kept you out of the line of fire, and this time it’s more or less a map of where the fire is.
The Curriculum and Assessment Review reported last November that it trimmed GCSE exam time and kept the system broadly as it is, which I’m not going to pretend I’m surprised by. You don’t rebuild national exams in a year. But employers aren’t waiting for it. In TestGorilla’s survey last year, half of UK employers said they’d dropped degree requirements. Half. Picture the parents’ evening where you tell a room full of people paying for the degree that one employer in two has stopped asking to see it. They’re looking at something else instead, whether you can actually do the thing, and mostly they’re testing for it themselves because the certificate stopped telling them.
There’s a trainee accountant in chapter 4 called Fatima, a composite, who passed every exam, did every year-end, did everything she was told. Then the promotion criteria changed to something about AI-augmented audit methodology and two people who’d been playing with the tools got promoted instead. Nobody failed her. The exams she passed were real and the criteria moved underneath her anyway. I think about her a lot when people talk to me about grades.
I’m not saying grades don’t matter, to be clear. They still open doors, probably for a good while yet, and a kid with good grades is better off than a kid without them. In chapter 13 I argue for assessing the actual capabilities alongside grades, decision-making and problem solving and so on, weighted roughly evenly, rather than throwing grades out. Alongside. The grade just shouldn’t be the whole plan, and in most of the conversations I have with parents, it kind of is the whole plan.
At the end of the event, one parent hit the nail on the head with “So keep going on the grades and the education as it’s important, but make sure they go out and get real lived experience, work or build things…make mistakes and so on..”
The Next Rung has the exam argument in chapter 13. It’s out in paperback on 19 January from Practical Inspiration Publishing, pre-orders at thenextrung.co.
Ask your teenager which of their subjects they could get ChatGPT to do the homework for. Then ask yourself which of those subjects you’re paying for tutoring in.

The Next Rung is a book on how AI is quietly dismantling the middle of knowledge work, and what you can do about it before the market decides for you: pre-order it before it publishes in January.

